YTMND talk:Proposed Rules
Discuss the rules or suggest your own.
Contents
- 1 Spamming
- 2 Obscenity, Racism, Harassment, and shock value
- 3 General use of pornography
- 4 Creating to or linking sites or comments glorifying generally illegal actions
- 5 Voting Trends
- 6 Grouping up to push an agenda
- 7 User Moderation Abuse
- 8 Use of alternate accounts
- 9 Meta Data
- 10 Just generally being a dumb idiot
- 11 Trying not to get caught
- 12 Miscellaneous
Spamming
Define real effort. --RySenkari
I think it means "not sticking random images with random sounds." Classic style sites get a little bit of a pass in that way, because the image and sound often go together in an important way to make a joke. Taking images/sounds from the internet and uploading them to YTMND without reasonable modification would break that rule. BTape 03:34, January 15, 2008 (CST)
Obscenity, Racism, Harassment, and shock value
Define unnecessary amount. --RySenkari
This one is up to a moderator's judgment, unless a consensus can be reached on a boundary. BTape 03:34, January 15, 2008 (CST)
General use of pornography
Creating to or linking sites or comments glorifying generally illegal actions
Voting Trends
Telling people how to vote is retarded, but whatever. --RySenkari
While some of the rules that fall under voting trends may be difficult to enforce, such as "revenge voting," I think there do need to be limits on the abusive voting habits that plague the site. BTape 03:34, January 15, 2008 (CST)
So upvoting is banned? Even if there's a good reason? I only click on a site if I'm pretty sure I'm gonna like it, that's why most of my votes are 5s. You want me to deliberately try to view shitty sites? --RySenkari
Grouping up to push an agenda
User Moderation Abuse
Does incorrectly mean blatantly labeling an NSFW site of yours SFW, or does it also extend to being wrong about a borderline site? --RySenkari
The punishments outlined currently are probably too harsh, but that can be changed. Yes, incorrectly marking a "borderline site" would fall under this rule. The planned moderation system may or may not have the same NSFW strictness it has now, though. BTape 03:34, January 15, 2008 (CST)
Use of alternate accounts
Meta Data
Oh God I'm fucked. --Kassius 06:46, January 14, 2008 (CST)
All kinds of crazy, stupid shit here. This will kill a lot of good sites if you do this. --RySenkari
The punishments for improper citation might be lowered, but the emphasis is still put on crediting your sources. BTape 03:34, January 15, 2008 (CST)
